Apartment Guide

Houses for rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY

W Neck Rd and Shore Rd, Shelter Island Heights, New York 11965
$13,000
1 Bed$13,000Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 749-0500

Waverly Pl and Spring Garden Ave, Shelter Island, New York 11964
$11,000
3 Beds$11,000Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 2 days ago
(631) 749-0500

Grand Ave and Summerfield Pl, Shelter Island, New York 11964
$2,000
5 Beds$2,000Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 2 days ago
(631) 749-0500
Write A Review
What would you tell others about your current residence?
Add Your Review

NY-114 and N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, New York 11964
$7,500
3 Beds$7,500Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 749-0500

5 Westmoreland Drive, Shelter Island, New York 11964
$2,500
3 Beds$2,500Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 767-7923

8 Gazon Road, Shelter Island, New York 11964
$5,500
4 Beds$5,500Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(516) 248-9494

Northfork

475 North Street, Greenport, New York 11944
$2,100
2 Beds$2,100Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 941-4111

Tims Trail and Old Buck Run, Shelter Island, New York 11964
$8,000
5 Beds$8,000Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 749-0500

Northfork

475 North Road, Greenport, New York 11944
$2,300
3 Beds$2,300Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 941-4111

Heron Ln and Sandpiper Rd, Shelter Island, New York 11964
$12,000
4 Beds$12,000Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 749-0500

Northfork

11930 Main Road, East Marion, New York 11939
$2,700
5 Beds$2,700Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 543-2009

The Hamptons

18 Norfolk Street, East Hampton, New York 11937
$1,300
4 Beds$1,300Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(718) 263-4700

Northfork

3830 Ole Jule Lane, Mattituck, New York 11952
$2,250
4 Beds$2,250Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 929-8400

The Hamptons

14 Argonne Road East, Hampton Bays, New York 11946
$14,000
1 Bed$14,000Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 728-8070

The Hamptons

1 Gardenia Avenue, Hampton Bays, New York 11946
$2,500
3 Beds$2,500Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 728-8070

Northfork

86 Park Road, Riverhead, New York 11901
$1,800
1 Bed$1,800Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(516) 410-3063

Northfork

53 Hillcrest Drive, Calverton, New York 11933
$5,000
2 Beds$5,000Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(631) 588-4663

The Hamptons

3 Hatcher Road, Quogue, New York 11959
$4,000
2 Beds$4,000Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 14 days ago
(917) 608-5736

56 Washington Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
$1,150
2 Beds$1,150Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 5 days ago
(860) 436-9955

31 Georgiana Street, New London, Connecticut 06320
$1,650
3 Beds$1,650Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(860) 288-4117

Average Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY

  • Studio: $1893
  • 1 bedroom: $2058
  • 2 bedrooms: $2612
  • 3 bedrooms: $3516