Apartment Guide

Houses for rent in Middletown, NY

Mountain Spring Dr., Sparta, New Jersey 07871
$3,800
3 Beds$3,800
Current Rent Specials
(877) 844-1578

8 West Main Street, Middletown, New York 10940
$1,300
2 Beds$1,300Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 610-6065

19 State Street, Middletown, New York 10940
$1,800
3 Beds$1,800Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 610-6065

What do you think of Middletown?

Think it’s great? Or not so much? Share your favorite spots, or let people know what to avoid. We’d love to have your opinion.

33 Prospect Avenue, Middletown, New York 10940
$1,300
2 Beds$1,300Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 12 days ago
(845) 475-8559

28 Myrtle Avenue, Middletown, New York 10940
$1,750
3 Beds$1,750Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 610-6065

12 Royce Avenue, Middletown, New York 10940
$1,700
3 Beds$1,700Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 610-6065

67 Deer Court Drive, Middletown, New York 10940
$1,490
2 Beds$1,490Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 610-6065

26 Wedgewood Lane, Middletown, New York 10940
$2,000
4 Beds$2,000Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 610-6065

159 Main Street, Goshen, New York 10924
$650
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 634-1034

24 South Main Street, Florida, New York 10921
$1,175
2 Beds$1,175Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 783-0004

44 High Street, Chester, New York 10918
$1,500
1 Bed$1,500Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
(845) 469-1234

376 Kaisertown Road, Montgomery, New York 12549
$2,200
3 Beds$2,200Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 457-9174

728 Roosa Gap Road, Bloomingburg, New York 12721
$1,050
2 Beds$1,050Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 457-9174

107 Homestead Avenue, Maybrook, New York 12543
$1,200
2 Beds$1,200Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 457-9174

610 Hill Avenue, Walden, New York 12586
$1,700
3 Beds$1,700Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 457-9174

41 Prospect Street, Westtown, New York 10998
$1,700
3 Beds$1,700Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 610-6065

21 Walnut Street, Montgomery, New York 12549
$2,500
4 Beds$2,500Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 457-9174

85 Red Barn Road, Pine Bush, New York 12566
$1,700
4 Beds$1,700Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 457-9174

130 Maple Avenue, Pine Bush, New York 12566
$850
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 457-9174

26 Peddler Hill Road, Monroe, New York 10950
$1,200
1 Bed$1,200Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 13 hours ago
Fresh
(845) 610-6065

Average Rent in Middletown, NY

  • Studio: $2703
  • 1 bedroom: $2547
  • 2 bedrooms: $3075
  • 3 bedrooms: $3979