1. Home

Houses for Rent in New Castle, IN

127 Properties

Search by Property Type

Local Guide

See what New Castle, IN has to offer.

What Renters Like and Dislike

What Renters Like and Dislike About New Castle

Evetything, McDonald's, McDonald's McDonald's mcdonalds McDonald's McDonald's McDonald's mcdonalds mcdoncalds

We go to coffee shops, there are nice restaurants, we are right next to Prospect Park so we go there a lot, it's a huge perk! And it's just beautiful here, just walking around is gorgeous and pleasant.

It is quiet. It is close to a park. Neighbors are polite. Yards are well kept. It is pet friendly. Kids play outside.

I like that it's close to a school, that makes me feel safer. It's close to a gas station and some other business which makes it convenient.

Everything is within walking distance and there are so many different places to go; most things you could want are easily accessible. It's pretty safe and although there has been crime, you don't hear about it as often as in other neighborhoods. As a woman I feel safe walking around during the early hours, like when I go to the gym down the block at 6 am.

The people here are pleasant to be around and if there is anything, the police are quick to deal with it,The neighborhood is also full of amenities and shops

Who Lives Here

New Castle Demographics

Education

High School

59%

Associate's

27%

Bachelor's

9%

Master's

4%

Doctorate

0%

Family Size

2 people

45%

3 people

27%

4 people

16%

5 people

9%

6+ people

5%

Household Income

0-50k

62%

50-100k

29%

100-150k

7%

150-200k

1%

200k+

1%

Age

0-10

13%

10-20

12%

20-45

30%

45-65

27%

65+

19%

Affordability

How expensive is it in New Castle?

Percentage: 4/54/5

Renters gave this area a 4 out of 5 for affordability

Rent Trends

Studio1 Bed2 Beds3 Beds
May '24-$871$934$1178
Apr '24-$934$979$1178
Mar '24-$934$974$1112
Feb '24-$934$974$1112
Jan '24-$879$897$1146
Dec '23-$848$897$1130
Nov '23-$834$922$1146
Oct '23-$840$909$1136
Sep '23-$841$909$1136
Aug '23-$825$909$1167
Jul '23-$828$884$1167
Jun '23-$816$879$1167
May '23-$829$879$1167

*The rent information included in this summary is based on a median calculation of multifamily rental property inventory on Apartment Guide and Rent.com over the past 12-months and is for illustrative purposes only. This information does not constitute a pricing guarantee or financial advice related to the rental market.

Getting Around New Castle

New Castle Transportation

Commute Time

0-15 Mins

50%

15-30 Mins

17%

30-40 Mins

9%

40-60 Mins

14%

60+ Mins

10%

Transportation Scores

Percentage: 3737

Walk Score®

Walkable

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Has Sidewalks

Yes

Say 3 of 6 renters

Percentage: 4444

Bike Score®

Bike Friendly

Yes

Say 4 of 6 renters

What Renters Are Saying

New Castle Features

Busy Streets

No

Say 6 of 6 renters

Area Has Litter

No

Say 6 of 6 renters

Area Has Kids Play Outside

Yes

Say 5 of 6 renters

Mostly Older Buildings

No

Say 5 of 6 renters

Nearby Parks

Yes

Say 5 of 6 renters

Near Schools

Yes

Say 5 of 6 renters

Pet Friendly

Yes

Say 5 of 6 renters

Good Place To Raise A Family

Yes

Say 5 of 6 renters

Safe For Families

Yes

Say 5 of 6 renters

Noise Late At Night

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Area Has Potholes

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Quiet Area

Yes

Say 3 of 6 renters

Well Lit

Yes

Say 3 of 6 renters

Maintained Yards

Yes

Say 3 of 6 renters

Near Highways

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Mostly Newer Buildings

No

Say 5 of 6 renters

Near Downtown

No

Say 5 of 6 renters

Near Grocery Stores

No

Say 5 of 6 renters

Nice Views

No

Say 5 of 6 renters

Tree Lined Streets

No

Say 5 of 6 renters

New Castle Education

Schools

Percentage: 4/54/5

School Score

How satisfied do renters feel with the schools in this area.

Top Schools in New Castle

Information provided by GreatSchools. To verify school enrollment eligibility, contact the school district directly.

What You Need to Know

Renter Articles