Tiffany Maberry

There’s no way around it – you need extra cash. While selling blood plasma may have crossed your mind, there are easier ways to pad your bank account. Have you thought about trying to sell stuff you no longer want or need online?

ebay vs. craigslist


From furniture to textbooks and even the most random knick-knacks, you’d be surprised what people are willing to pay for stuff you’ve long neglected. The hard part may be determining the best vehicle for getting your stuff into a buyer’s hands. Craigslist and eBay are two popular options, but which one is right for you? Apartment Guide explains the good and the bad of each.

Rent Going Up? 5 Ways to Save Money So You Don't Feel the Pinch

Craigslist Prosebay vs. craigslist

  • It's free.
  • Ideal for selling locally.
  • You can list just about anything for sale.
  • No shipping hassles.
  • Easy to sell large items.


Craigslist Cons

  • Your ad can be flagged or removed at any time.
  • You may have to continue re-listing your item since ads are pushed further down the page as new ones are posted.
  • A possible influx of email spam.
  • Last minute negotiations.
  • Low-ball offers.
  • Buyers that don't show up.
  • Having to drive out to meet buyers.

Sweep Away Bad Budgeting Habits with a Savings Plan

Craigslist Tips

  • Know which items sell well on the site. Furniture and technology are popular on Craigslist. Smaller items like clothes, shoes, and books are not.
  • Avoid posting your phone number, address or photos of yourself.
  • Use the auto-generated email address provided by Craigslist instead of your personal email.
  • Meet with buyers during the day in a public, well-lit area.
  • Bring someone with you.
  • Accept cash only.
  • Do some research on how to spot counterfeit money.

 eBay Prosebay vs. craigslist

  • Ideal for items that you can't or won't sell locally, like clothes, shoes, and books.
  • Seller protection is available for most items.
  • Bidding makes the price of your item increase, maybe more than expected.
  • You can sell nationwide or even worldwide.

eBay Cons

  • Listing fees do apply.
  • It’s difficult to estimate what shipping will cost, and you’ll be responsible if the package weighs more than expected.
  • There’s a time limit.
  • The possibility of negative feedback left on your seller profile page.
  • Hard to sell large items.

6 Ways to Save Money on Your Apartment Search

eBay Tips

  • List items on days when people are most likely to be looking. Most people get paid on Fridays or days like the 1st, 15th or last day of the month. Also, think about if the item you're selling is seasonal. For example, it would make sense to post textbooks for sale at the beginning of the semester in September or January.
  • Make sure your item descriptions are completely accurate and as detailed as possible. Think in terms of what words buyers might type into eBay's search bar.
  • Check similar items sold on the site to see how much the bid started at, how much it sold for, and how much shipping was. This will give you a general idea of how your item might perform.

How to Grocery Shop on a Budget

Do you have any experience selling stuff on Craigslist or eBay? Tell us about it on our Facebook page!


Photo credit: Shutterstock / Africa Studio



About The Author

Tiffany Maberry is a content contributor for the Apartment Guide Blog. She's been writing professionally for over 10 years and enjoys working in the social media space. Find Tiffany on Google+.