Floor Plans & Pricing

2 Beds2.5 Bath
$1,015–$1,1251877+ sqft
1 Available
2 Beds2.5 Bath
$1,050–$1,2502035+ sqft
Prices, specials, features and availability subject to change.

Ratings & Reviews

Review McNaughten Woods!

Select a star to begin your review.
Overall Ratings
(7 Ratings)

7 Reviews for McNaughten Woods

Sort By:

As you can see there are a lot of bad reviews, The pictures on the website are all false, there are NO wood floors, updated appliances or cabinets( all since the 80's ), No ceiling fans, gym/whirlpool is maintenance storage room, no on time maintenance work is done poorly, NOT a gated community(does not work half the time), basements flood all the time which caused mold and mildew( harmful to your health ), allows tenants burn fire pits on patios(against state fire codes), garages used as storage units(against their own lease rules), No balcony( just a patio ) will not handle issues with unruly neighbors and children who destroy property, flowers, signs, peak in windows(like Michael Meyers ) but tells you to handle it, then the parents call the Police on you and the complex believes them when you did nothing, I needed a new refrig. and was given a used one w/no shelves was told they do not come with them, patio door rotting away, raise the rent up $20-$100 per/year. 10 years ago staff was very helpful, polite, and handled things the way you would expect to be when you pay that for rent. The next management a little better but then left, then came Bettina and Terry; Complex went down-hill like a runaway train. The Current staff is very Rude, lazy and not willing to help just sit in the office all day wondering when they can go to lunch. Does not doing anything to improve the complex or for tenants...IF there was a 1/2 star rating I would give it that, IF you want a great area to live, even if you have to pay a little bit more, drive by McNaughten woods and never look back or else you will have nightmares and regrets.


Was this helpful?
We are deeply dismayed to hear you have not had the five-star experience you deserve in our community. The comfort and satisfaction of our residents are of the utmost importance to our team, so while we understand you do not have a high opinion us at this time, we urge you to please contact or visit us in the office when you can. We would greatly appreciate getting to sit down with you to discuss these issues in greater detail and to work with you to improve your stay soon. Thank you.


From what I hear it's a great place to live an interest in some information so please contact me thank you very much Lynn


Was this helpful?
Thank you for this review! We are thrilled to know that you've heard positive recommendations for our community. Our office team would be more than happy to provide additional information and assist you, so please either give us a call or swing by the office so we can do so.


I have lived her greater than 12 years. This place has deteriorated. I though we was on the upswing with the former office manager (DJ). Now there is a lady name Terri, who does all the work, and Batima who has a very bad attitude managing the place. I went in the rental office recently, I could not believe how nasty that place was. OMG!. That was a deal breaker for me. As soon as my lease is up, I will be moving out of McNaughten Hood!


Was this helpful?
We're dismayed to read that your experience with our community hasn't been to your liking as of late. Our team cares deeply about our residents, and we apologize if we gave you another impression. We'd like the chance to sit down with you and discuss some of your concerns, as well as improve upon our original communication moving forward, so we encourage you to stop by our office, thank you.


Older apartments with the classic feel. Grounds are very peaceful and shady with well maintained clean grounds. POol is great and staff are wonderful. Neighbors are friendly. Wonderful amount of space for an apartment. I love it!


Was this helpful?

I loved living in McNaughten Woods and the repairs were done timely. However, communication with the female resident manager who took over in 2014 was difficult because she had such a nasty demeanor and attitude. I have moved since due to the unpleasantness received from her and her unfair statements.


Was this helpful?


Apartment Features

  • Air Conditioning
  • Cable Ready
  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Dishwasher
  • Fireplace
  • Oversized Closets
  • Washer & Dryer Connections
  • Garbage Disposal
  • Patio
  • Refrigerator

Special Features

  • Pets

Community Features

  • Covered Parking
  • Extra Storage
  • Garage
  • Gated Access
  • High Speed Internet Access
  • Swimming Pool
  • Carport
  • On Site Maintenance
  • On Site Management
  • Corporate
  • Pet Friendly

Additional Features

  • Garage included
  • Woodburning fireplace
  • Two master bedrooms
  • 2 1/2 baths
  • Finished basements w/ storage
  • Dogs and cats welcome
  • European-designed kitchens
  • Outdoor pool, hot tub
  • Two Bedrooms each with private bath
  • Gated community
  • Patio
  • Dishwasher
  • Walk-in closets
  • Extra Storage
  • *In select units
View More +


Pet Friendly
  • Weight restriction: 75lbs
  • Dogs and Cats Welcome
Cats OK
  • Deposit: $300
  • Plus $35/month fee
Dogs OK
  • Deposit: $300
  • Plus $35/month fee

Property Details

McNaughten Woods - Columbus

McNaughten Woods

LIVE THE PLAZA LIFE! Escape to the cozy, country retreat of McNaughten Woods and find yourself surrounded by the old-world charm of a European village. Tucked away from the hustle and bustle of the city, yet close enough for convenience; McNaughten Woods offers a truly unique apartment community.

Lease Terms


Office Hours

Open Today

Show All Hours


Rating 6

French Run Elementary School

1200 Epworth Ave, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Rating 4

Hannah J. Ashton Middle School

1482 Jackson St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Rating default

Liberty Christian Academy

4938 Beatrice Dr, Columbus, OH 43227
PK-12 & ungraded
Rating default

Columbus Torah Academy

181 Noe Bixby Rd, Columbus, OH 43213
Rating default

Arts And College Preparatory Academy

4401 Hilton Corporate Dr, Columbus, OH 43232
Rating default


1555 Graham Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
All content about schools and school districts is provided by GreatSchools, a third party. Apartment Guide does not create, develop, contribute to, or endorse this content.

Check Availability

(614) 372-8117
By submitting this form, you agree to RentPath's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.