$SlideshowTourVideo

Rent Pet Friendly Apartments in Pine Island, New York

2 Underhill Road, Middletown, New York 10940
Pet Friendly
$1,425+
(1 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,425+
2 Beds$1,640+
3 Beds$1,900+
Current Rent Specials
Top Rated
(855) 233-2643

4 Center St, Sussex, New Jersey 07461
Pet Friendly
$1,000+
(3 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,0005 units left
2 Beds$1,150+6 units available
Current Rent Specials
Updated 5 days ago
(609) 301-5927

201 Genung Street, Middletown, New York 10940
Pet Friendly
$1,270+
(2 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,270
2 Beds$1,372+Only 1 unit left
3 BedsPlease Call
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
Updated 3 days ago
(845) 648-3470

What do you think of Pine Island?

Think it’s great? Or not so much? Share your favorite spots, or let people know what to avoid. We’d love to have your opinion.

300 Northwoods Road, Middletown, New York 10940
Pet Friendly
$1,475+
1 Bed$1,475+
2 Beds$1,665+
Current Rent Specials
(845) 531-4627

225 Berkman Dr, Middletown, New York 10941
Pet Friendly
$1,330+
(57 Ratings)
StudioPlease Call
1 Bed$1,330+Only 1 unit left
2 Beds$1,515+Only 3 units left
3 BedsPlease Call
Current Rent Specials
Updated 3 days ago
(845) 694-3150

2 Swartswood Road, Newton, New Jersey 07860
Pet Friendly
$1,120+
2 Beds$1,320
Current Rent Specials
(609) 642-2581

17 Brewster Rd, Cornwall, New York 12518
Pet Friendly
$1,800+
3 Beds$1,800+6 units available
Current Rent Specials
(914) 222-1815

101 Drake Dr, Newburgh, New York 12550
Pet Friendly
$1,525+
1 Bed$1,525+Only 1 unit left
2 Beds$1,820+Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
(845) 440-5074

2 Hazen Court, Wayne, New Jersey 07470
Pet Friendly
$1,795+
(1 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,795+Only 1 unit left
2 Beds$2,095+Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
(973) 988-4056

41 West Prospect Street, Waldwick, New Jersey 07463
Pet Friendly
$1,875+
Studio$1,875+
1 Bed$2,175+
2 BedsPlease Call
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
Updated 4 days ago
(862) 801-0616

48 Henry Court, Mount Arlington, New Jersey 07856
Pet Friendly
$1,525+
(38 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,525+Only 3 units left
2 Beds$1,745+Only 2 units left
Updated 3 days ago
(973) 531-4393

2 Lake View Drive, Peekskill, New York 10566
Pet Friendly
$1,575+
1 Bed$1,575+Only 3 units left
2 Beds$2,300+Only 1 unit left
3 BedsPlease Call
Current Rent Specials
Updated 3 days ago
(845) 271-5119

194 Tompkins Avenue, Beacon, New York 12508
Pet Friendly
$785+
(3 Ratings)
Studio$785+
1 Bed$850+
2 Beds$1,000+
3 Beds$1,191+
Current Rent Specials
(845) 809-4006

1 Hillside Drive, Mount Arlington, New Jersey 07856
Pet Friendly
$1,550+
1 Bed$1,550+Only 1 unit left
2 Beds$2,010+Only 2 units left
Current Rent Specials
(973) 457-7518

1100 Parsippany Boulevard, Parsippany, New Jersey 07054
Pet Friendly
$1,270+
(10 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,270+
2 Beds$1,615+
Current Rent Specials
(862) 263-4071

13 Laurel Garden Dr, South Fallsburg, New York 12779
Pet Friendly
$825+
(4 Ratings)
StudioPlease Call
2 Beds$900+
Current Rent Specials
(845) 262-6758

1715 U.S. Highway 46, Parsippany, New Jersey 07054
Pet Friendly
$2,175+
(6 Ratings)
1 Bed$2,175+
2 Beds$2,535+
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
Updated 6 hours ago
Top RatedFresh
(862) 305-0473

Average Rent in Pine Island, NY

  • Studio: $2831
  • 1 bedroom: $2561
  • 2 bedrooms: $3134
  • 3 bedrooms: $4230