Skip to Content (Press Enter)
  1. Home

Apartments for rent in Middletown, NY

55 Properties

Local Guide

See what Middletown, NY has to offer.

All About

Living in Middletown, NY

The town of Middletown, New York is home to slightly more than 28,000 residents. With an average age of just over 37, the city's residents skew younger than most cities in New York. By a small 54%-46% margin, homeowners are slightly more prevalent than renters in Middletown. The average rent of $1,191/month is just below the state average.

Middletown has a relatively high concentration of residents older than 25 who have earned a high school degree or equivalent (23%) compared to the national average. Furthermore, 8% have a Bachelor's degree and 4% possess a Master's degree or Doctorate. There are three primary industries in Middletown: retail, healthcare, and entertainment. Combined, these industries account for 23% of the city's labor force. Meanwhile, in terms of job function, 8% of the city's population works in sales, which ranks as the top career path in the city. Middletown workers earn an average annual income of around $69K, less than the New York average. The city's average income also falls below the national average of $73,345.

Middletown has an average commute time of about 32 minutes. Many residents (42%) drive their car or truck to work, while public transportation isn't used much. Relatively few residents commute to work on foot.

What Renters Like and Dislike

What Renters Like and Dislike About Middletown

Its close to shopping centers, highways, and only 90 min from nyc. New breweries are popping up downtown but theres a lot to still fix.

We are in walking distance to our schools. We have one of the biggest and best parade. We have a nice gym for everyone to play at.

My neighborhood is unique in the fact that there are a lot of children who continue to play together . We like to go to the near by parks for picnics and partiies.

We have many parks and beautiful outdoor areas nearby. We have good ethnic restaurants nearby., such as Chinese and Asian.

close to highways and stores are within a short drive. neighbors are mostly nice and keep to themselves mostly. I live just inside the better school district.

Who Lives Here

Middletown Demographics

Education

High School

33%

Associate's

20%

Bachelor's

8%

Master's

4%

Doctorate

35%

Family Size

2 people

32%

3 people

24%

4 people

25%

5 people

11%

6+ people

8%

Household Income

0-50k

45%

50-100k

29%

100-150k

14%

150-200k

6%

200k+

6%

Age

0-10

13%

10-20

14%

20-45

34%

45-65

25%

65+

14%

Affordability

How expensive is it in Middletown?

Percentage: 4/54/5

Renters gave this area a 4 out of 5 for affordability

Rent Trends

Studio1 Bed2 Beds3 Beds
Sep '23$1500$1897$2085$2400
Aug '23$1500$1897$2085$2400
Jul '23$1500$1812$2037$2400
Jun '23$1500$1715$1952$2400
May '23$1462$1715$1985$2380
Apr '23$1462$1842$2157$2380
Mar '23$1462$1787$2157$2400
Feb '23$1462$1712$1952$2385
Jan '23$1462$1657$1892$2380
Dec '22$1462$1670$1892$2380
Nov '22$1462$1680$1892$2380
Oct '22$1462$1680$1895$2380
Sep '22$1462$1680$1895$2380

*The rent information included in this summary is based on a median calculation of multifamily rental property inventory on Apartment Guide and Rent.com over the past 12-months and is for illustrative purposes only. This information does not constitute a pricing guarantee or financial advice related to the rental market.

Getting Around Middletown

Middletown Transportation

Commute Time

0-15 Mins

32%

15-30 Mins

31%

30-40 Mins

10%

40-60 Mins

11%

60+ Mins

16%

Transportation Scores

Percentage: 3939

Walk Score®

Walkable

No

Say 3 of 4 renters

Has Sidewalks

No

Say 3 of 4 renters

Percentage: 3232

Bike Score®

Bike Friendly

No

Say 3 of 4 renters

Top Scores: Grocery, Restaurant, Retail

Things To Do In Middletown

Top Score

Grocery Stores

4/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Solid grocery game.

  1. A high number of grocery stores per resident
  2. 60% more grocery stores than average
  3. 48% more grocery stores than areas of a similar size

Restaurants

4/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Cooking skills not required in Middletown.

  1. A high number of restaurants per resident
  2. 56% more restaurants than average
  3. 18% more restaurants than areas of a similar size

Retail Shops

4/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Middletown's retail scene is in the bag.

  1. A high number of shops per resident
  2. Significantly more shops than average
  3. 88% more shops than areas of a similar size

Nightlife

3/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Happy hour starts at six around here.

  1. A high number of bars and clubs per resident
  2. 34% more bars and clubs than average
  3. 25% more bars and clubs than areas of a similar size

Gas Stations

3/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Bumper sticker city. This place is good for filling up.

  1. A high number of gas stations per resident
  2. Significantly more gas stations than average
  3. 42% more gas stations than areas of a similar size

Parks

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

There's fresh air to be had here.

  1. Few parks per resident
  2. 24% fewer parks than average
  3. 44% fewer parks than areas of a similar size

Pet Services

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Who's an ok boy? Middletown doesn't deserve many treats.

  1. A high number of pet facilities per resident
  2. 85% more pet facilities than average
  3. A standard number of pet facilities compared to areas of a similar size

Coffee

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The coffee scene is lukewarm in Middletown.

  1. Few coffee shops per resident
  2. 65% fewer coffee shops than average
  3. 72% fewer coffee shops than areas of a similar size

Health and Fitness

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

You'll have to workout somewhere else to keep fit.

  1. Few gyms per resident
  2. 15% more gyms than average
  3. 26% fewer gyms than areas of a similar size

Fine Arts

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

You gotta Van Gogh somewhere else for art.

  1. Few fine art centers per resident
  2. 100% fewer fine art centers than average
  3. 100% fewer fine art centers than areas of a similar size

Medical Care

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

We have a bone to pick with this Middletown's access to medical care.

  1. A high number of medical facilities per resident
  2. 69% fewer medical facilities than average
  3. 29% fewer medical facilities than areas of a similar size

What Renters Are Saying

Middletown Features

Busy Streets

No

Say 4 of 4 renters

Noise Late At Night

No

Say 4 of 4 renters

Area Has Litter

No

Say 4 of 4 renters

Area Has Kids Play Outside

Yes

Say 3 of 4 renters

Near Grocery Stores

Yes

Say 3 of 4 renters

Near Schools

Yes

Say 3 of 4 renters

Pet Friendly

Yes

Say 3 of 4 renters

Quiet Area

Yes

Say 3 of 4 renters

Good Place To Raise A Family

Yes

Say 3 of 4 renters

Safe For Families

Yes

Say 3 of 4 renters

Near Highways

Yes

Say 2 of 4 renters

Nearby Parks

Yes

Say 2 of 4 renters

Area Has Potholes

Yes

Say 2 of 4 renters

Mostly Older Buildings

Yes

Say 3 of 4 renters

Near Downtown

No

Say 3 of 4 renters

Nice Views

No

Say 3 of 4 renters

Tree Lined Streets

No

Say 3 of 4 renters

Well Lit

No

Say 3 of 4 renters

Mostly Newer Buildings

No

Say 4 of 4 renters

Maintained Yards

No

Say 4 of 4 renters

Middletown Education

Schools

Percentage: 4/54/5

School Score

How satisfied do renters feel with the schools in this area.

Top Schools in Middletown

NRNo Rating

Truman Moon Elementary School

Public

NRNo Rating

Presidential Park Elementary School

Public

3/10

Maple Hill Elementary School

Grades K-5 • Public

2/10

William A Carter School

Grades K-5 • Public

4/10

Pakanasink Elementary School

Grades PK-5 • Public

3/10

Circleville Elementary School

Grades PK-5 • Public

Information provided by GreatSchools. To verify school enrollment eligibility, contact the school district directly.

All About

Living in Middletown, NY

The town of Middletown, New York is home to slightly more than 28,000 residents. With an average age of just over 37, the city's residents skew younger than most cities in New York. By a small 54%-46% margin, homeowners are slightly more prevalent than renters in Middletown. The average rent of $1,191/month is just below the state average.

Middletown has a relatively high concentration of residents older than 25 who have earned a high school degree or equivalent (23%) compared to the national average. Furthermore, 8% have a Bachelor's degree and 4% possess a Master's degree or Doctorate. There are three primary industries in Middletown: retail, healthcare, and entertainment. Combined, these industries account for 23% of the city's labor force. Meanwhile, in terms of job function, 8% of the city's population works in sales, which ranks as the top career path in the city. Middletown workers earn an average annual income of around $69K, less than the New York average. The city's average income also falls below the national average of $73,345.

Middletown has an average commute time of about 32 minutes. Many residents (42%) drive their car or truck to work, while public transportation isn't used much. Relatively few residents commute to work on foot.

Find Apartments in Nearby Neighborhoods