Rent 2 Bedroom Apartments in Middle Island, New York

248 Lake Pointe Cir, Middle Island, New York 11953
$1,730+
1 Bed$1,730+
2 Beds$1,860+
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
(631) 880-6253

100 Stonegate Way, Middle Island, New York 11953
$2,181+
1 Bed$1,777+
2 Beds$2,181+
3 Beds$2,350+
Current Rent Specials
Updated a day ago
Fresh
(631) 880-6057

325 Tudor Lane, Middle Island, New York 11953
$1,995+
1 Bed$1,760+
2 Beds$1,995+
Current Rent Specials
(631) 881-5135

What do you think of Middle Island?

Think it’s great? Or not so much? Share your favorite spots, or let people know what to avoid. We’d love to have your opinion.

45 Country Club Drive, Coram, New York 11727
$1,950+
(56 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,675+
2 Beds$1,950+
Current Rent Specials
(631) 888-3114

1 Brookwood Dr, Coram, New York 11727
$2,025+
1 Bed$1,725+
2 Beds$2,025+
Current Rent Specials
(631) 615-1613

9 Williams Blvd., Lake Grove, New York 11755
$2,465+
1 Bed$1,680+4 units left
2 Beds$2,465+
Current Rent Specials
Updated 8 hours ago
Fresh
(631) 615-4540

2200 Dolphin Lane, Holbrook, New York 11741
Pet Friendly
$2,595+
(376 Ratings)
1 Bed$2,050+8 units available
2 Beds$2,595+8 units available
Current Rent Specials
(631) 954-3146

1710 Devonshire Road, Hauppauge, New York 11788
$2,007+
(3 Ratings)
Studio$1,326+
1 Bed$1,721+
2 Beds$2,007+
3 Beds$2,600+
Current Rent Specials
Updated 15 hours ago
Fresh
(631) 865-1242

100 Terrace Road, Bayport, New York 11705
$2,030+
(66 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,525+Only 1 unit left
2 Beds$2,030+Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 8 hours ago
Fresh
(631) 438-1063

313 Avalon Circle, Smithtown, New York 11787
$2,565+
(372 Ratings)
1 Bed$2,321+
2 Beds$2,565+
3 Beds$3,100+
Updated 6 hours ago
Fresh
(631) 888-3121

1220 Orchid Circle, Bellport, New York 11713
$2,055+
(2 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,755+4 units left
2 Beds$2,055+4 units left
3 Beds$2,375+8 units available
Current Rent Specials
Updated 15 hours ago
Fresh
(631) 561-6024

234 River Ave, Patchogue, New York 11772
$2,000+
Studio$1,375+
1 Bed$1,650+
2 Beds$2,000+
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
(631) 419-7125

Broadway Ave, Holbrook, New York 11741
$2,195+
1 Bed$1,515+
2 Beds$2,195+
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
(631) 319-3136

211 Hawthorne Avenue # 9, Central Islip, New York 11722
$1,715+
Studio$1,550
1 Bed$1,500+10 units available
2 Beds$1,715+8 units available
3 Beds$2,450+
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
Updated 20 hours ago
Fresh
(844) 853-0772

5000 Townehouse Dr, Coram, New York 11727
$2,395
2 Beds$2,395
3 Beds$2,795
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
(631) 228-8991

400 Adams Way, Sayville, New York 11782
$2,425+
(72 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,965+
2 Beds$2,425+
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
(631) 240-4684

111 College Rd, Selden, New York 11784
$2,125+
1 Bed$1,620+
2 Beds$2,125+
Current Rent Specials
(631) 880-6251

50 Fairfield Way, Commack, New York 11725
$2,300+
1 Bed$1,975+
2 Beds$2,300+
Coupon & Current Rent Specials
(631) 850-4192

100 Vista View Drive, Farmingville, New York 11738
$2,225+
1 Bed$1,925+
2 Beds$2,225+
3 Beds$2,500+
Current Rent Specials
(631) 721-4472

One Charles Pond Drive, Coram, New York 11727
$2,314+
(267 Ratings)
1 Bed$1,755+Only 1 unit left
2 Beds$2,314+Only 1 unit left
Current Rent Specials
Updated 17 hours ago
Fresh
(631) 721-9686

Average Rent in Middle Island, NY

  • Studio: $2686
  • 1 bedroom: $2523
  • 2 bedrooms: $3045
  • 3 bedrooms: $3939