Apartment Guide
  1. Home
  2. New Jersey
  3. West Orange
  4. West Mill Gardens
(973) 850-0486

Special Offer

Luxury Community

West Mill Gardens

115 Old Short Hls Rd, West Orange, NJ 07052
4 units available now
1 Bed$1,399–$1,825
2 Beds$1,920–$2,195
3 Beds$2,235–$2,385

Tour from Home

Live video tours and 3D tours to help you explore from home.

3D Tours and Videos

West Mill Gardens, West Orange, NJ
3D Tour
West Mill Gardens, West Orange, NJ
Video Slideshow
Person engaged in a live video property tour on a mobile device

Live Video Tours

This property may offer live video tours through apps like FaceTime and Zoom.

Floor Plans & Pricing

$1.85/sq.ft. - The Astor
1 Bed1 Bath
$1,399–$1,675755 sqft
1 Available
$1.94/sq.ft. - The Belvedere
1 Bed1 Bath
$1,535–$1,825790 sqft
1 Available
$1.83/sq.ft. - The Chelsea
2 Beds1.5 Bath
$2,045–$2,1951120 sqft
1 Available
$1.71/sq.ft. - The Devonshire
2 Beds1 Bath
$1,920–$2,1701120 sqft
1 Available
$1.88/sq.ft. - The Excelsior-TownHome
3 Beds1.5 Bath
$2,235–$2,3851190 sqft
Prices, specials, features and availability subject to change.

Hot Deals

Advertised Rents are on Select Apartments for a Limited Time Only! Call Today for Details!

Ratings & Reviews

West Mill Gardens

Select a star to begin your review.
Overall Ratings
(142 Ratings)

90 Reviews for West Mill Gardens

Sort By:
Certified Resident

People are great!! Maintenance has been wonderful to respond quickly! Office staff are pleasant and helpful!


Was this helpful?
Dear Resident, Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us; it gives others a sense of what it is like to live at West Mill Gardens. We hope that you will continue to be happy living at our community for many years! Sincerely, West Mill Gardens Management


Certified Resident

Respond immediately to any problem or concern


Susan O.

Was this helpful?
Thank you Susan! We love the feedback!


Been denied don't know why have not receive deposit yet 30 days later now


Was this helpful?

So far it hasn't been awful- but the washer/dryers are always broken and the laundry room is filthy. For what we pay a month I do expect a little bit better. I also find that there are issues in our apartment with little things being broken here and there- such as electric outlet covers being loose and cabinets being faulty.


Was this helpful?
Dear Anonymous, we would like the opportunity to address your concerns, unfortunately without a name we are locate you in our data base. Please reach out to us directly at (973) 731-6282 when you have a chance. Thank you, and we look forward to hearing from you. Sincerely, West Mill Gardens Management


I've been here several months. I have neighbors above me. They slam the doors every time they go in and out and I can hear them opening and slamming the kitchen drawers. They sound like elephants walking around. It's obvious they don't have a stitch of carpeting in their unit. This should be enforced. I am awakened every day when they get up to go to work, and they work every other weekend, so even, then there's no break from it. The unit itself is nice, the grounds are well kept, but parking is an issue. It stinks not having assigned parking, especially if you come home after 6 pm. Several times I've had to park quite a distance from my building late at night, which I dislike. The lack of an in apartment washer and dryer is an issue. Though the building I'm in has a laundry room it's not cleaned regularly, several times the machines have malfunctioned and I've had to call. I would be willing to pay water in order to have my own washer and dryer. It's a pain hauling it outside the building . I doubt I'll stay here when my lease is up.


Was this helpful?
Dear Anonymous, Thank you for leaving feedback. Without a name we are unable to locate you in our database. Please reach out to us at (973) 731-6282 so we may identify ways to improve your experience. Sincerely, West Mill Gardens Management



Apartment Features

Air Conditioning
Cable Ready
Gas Range
Hardwood Flooring
New/Renovated Interior
Some Paid Utilities

Community Features

Emergency Maintenance
Laundry Facility
Public Transportation
Swimming Pool
Tennis Court(s)
Luxury Community

Additional Features

Heat and hot water included
Dishwasher and refrigerator
Base board hot water heat w/individual thermostate
Range with exhaust hood
Cable TV access
Garage parking available
Off-street parking
Verizon FiOS Available
Air conditioning
Tennis courts and playground
Swimming pool
All apartments are newly renovated
24-hour emergency maintenance
Mini-blinds on all windows
Off street Parking
Hardwood floors
Laundry room
Near by shopping

Pets Policy

  • Call for Policy


Garage Lot


  • $50 Application Fee
  • $200 Admin Fee

Property Details

West Mill Gardens

TO DO OUR PART TO MITIGATE THE RISK OF SPREAD OF COVID-19 OUR OFFICES WILL BE AVAILABLE BY PHONE AND IN-PERSON BY APPOINTMENT ONLY IF NECESSARY. CALL US! If you appreciate the difference between simply living and living well, you'll enjoy the difference at West Mill in West Orange. Enjoy the impeccably landscaped grounds, surrounding a private pool and tennis courts in an prestigious residential environment. Our spacious setting is rigorously maintained twenty-four hours a day in our newly renovated apartment homes.

Lease Terms

6-Month, 12-Month

Lease terms are variable. Please inquire with property staff. Our spacious apartments provide the perfect space for a home office or children's play area

Office Hours

In response to COVID-19, office hours and walk-in appointments may be limited.

Open until 5:00pm



Livingston Sr High School

30 Robert H Harp Dr
Grades 9-12 | Public
Apartments Near Livingston Sr High School
Great Schools®

Stepping Stones School

343 E Cedar St
Grades PK-2 | Private
Apartments Near Stepping Stones School
No Rating
Great Schools®

Far Brook School

52 Great Hills Rd
Grades PK-8 | Private
Apartments Near Far Brook School
No Rating
Great Schools®
*All content about schools and school districts is provided by GreatSchools, a third party. Apartment Guide does not create, develop, contribute to, or endorse this content.

Helpful Information

West Mill Gardens

(973) 850-0486

I'm interested in (optional)

Add Message +
By submitting this form, you agree to RentPath's 

People who viewed this apartment also viewed


© 2020 RentPath, LLC. All rights reserved. All photos, videos, text and other content are the property of RentPath, LLC. APARTMENT GUIDE and the APARTMENT GUIDE Trade Dress are registered trademarks of RentPath, LLC or its affiliates.

Apple, the Apple logo, iPad, and iPhone are trademarks of Apple Inc., registered in the U.S. and other countries. App Store is a service mark of Apple Inc.

Information is copyrighted and school data provided by GreatSchools.org. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Schools listed above are based on distance from the selected location and are just a sampling of the schools in the area. To find a particular school district, and how it relates to a specific apartment, please contact the apartment manager.

Download the ApartmentGuide.com app for Android and iOS