Apartment Features

  • Air Conditioning
  • Balcony
  • Cable Ready
  • Ceiling Fan(s)

Special Features

  • Pets

Community Features

  • Accepts Electronic Payments
  • Business Center
  • Emergency Maintenance
  • High Speed Internet Access

Additional Features

  • In-home washer/dryer options*
  • Dogs welcome*
  • Four laundry care centers
  • Covered parking
View More +


Pet Friendly
  • Weight restriction: 90lbs
  • $250.00 Non-Refundable Fee, $25.00 Monthly Pet Fee
Breed Restriction

Floor Plans & Pricing

The Brendonwood
1 Bed1 Bath
From $769644+ sqft
1 Available
The Brookhaven
1 Bed1 Bath
From $799682+ sqft
1 Available
The Charlevoix
2 Beds1 Bath
From $875810+ sqft
1 Available
The Commons
2 Beds1.5 Bath
From $950842+ sqft
1 Available
The Avalon
2 Beds1.5 Bath
From $999928+ sqft
1 Available
The Watson
2 Beds1.5 Bath
From $1,025980+ sqft
1 Available
The Salem
2 Beds1.5 Bath
From $1,050992+ sqft
1 Available
The Lawrence
2 Beds1.5 Bath
From $1,0991120+ sqft
1 Available
The Farmington
2 Beds1.5 Bath
From $1,1991400+ sqft
1 Available
The Devington
2 Beds2 Bath
From $1,1991056+ sqft
1 Available
The Kesslerwood
2 Beds2.5 Bath
From $1,2991704+ sqft
1 Available
The Beaumont
3 Beds2 Bath
From $1,0991032+ sqft
1 Available
The Sylvan
3 Beds2 Bath
From $1,2751467+ sqft
1 Available
The Castleton
3 Beds2.5 Bath
From $1,2501400+ sqft
1 Available
The Deville
3 Beds2.5 Bath
From $1,3251730+ sqft
1 Available
The Chesapeake
3 Beds3 Bath
From $1,4502234+ sqft
Prices, specials, features and availability subject to change.

Property Details

Cottages of Fall Creek - Indianapolis

Cottages of Fall Creek

Now Leasing NEWLY Renovated Apartment Homes - Unique Design, and Modern Amenities. Coming in 2019: NEW Clubhouse, NEW Fitness Center, NEW Swimming Pool, and much more. The Cottages of Fall Creek is conveniently located on the East side of Indianapolis at 56th and Shadeland Avenue. We are now offering 1, 2, & 3 bedroom designer-styled apartment homes as well as 2 & 3 bedroom townhomes. Our custom designs include soft-close espresso cabinets, white quartz countertops, vinyl wood-plank flooring, stainless steel appliances, brushed-nickel fixtures, and custom paint. Our pet friendly community has easy access to I-465, Broad Ripple and Downtown.

Lease Terms


Office Hours

Open Today

Show All Hours

Ratings & Reviews

Review Cottages of Fall Creek!

Select a star to begin your review.
Overall Ratings
(6 Ratings)

6 Reviews for Cottages of Fall Creek

Sort By:

While the Leasing Staff are very friendly. Management has change more times than I could have count within the 2 years I spent there. Not to mention how inflexible Management was with Military Personnel. Also the maintenance left a lot to be desired. Overall, it was the worst living experience I have had.


Was this helpful?
We apologize for your experience with the previous management company and we are sorry to hear you were less than satisfied with The Cottages of Fall Creek. Please feel free to contact us should you have any questions regarding the terms of the contract you signed with the former management, we are happy to help!
Best Regards,
The Team at The Cottages of Fall Creek


For this community to be under new management they are horrible!! Ive had my dish washer flood my kitchen water get in the dining room didnt get fixed til four days later. My garbage disposal fell from the sink that didnt get fixed until four days later. My doorknob fell off on my front entry door that did not get fixed until 4-5 days later. I love the price that I pay for a two bedroom townhouse but its hirrible living here.


Was this helpful?
We apologize for the issues you are currently facing with maintenance. Please contact Mary at (317)541-1224 or so we can make things right. We look forward to hearing from you and getting this completed for you.
The Team at Cottages of Fall Creek


I would never recommend living here. It's the end of May, A/C is out and has been for 3 weeks. No one has been over to fix it after daily calls about how hot it is. It's in the 90s today and my power went out.
They do not care about anyone living here. If you're on the fence about living here, choose somewhere else. The price is NOT worth it.


Was this helpful?
The Cottages of Fall Creek team works hard to provide 5-star service, and we are sorry to hear that your experience has been less than satisfactory. When it is convenient for you, please feel free to reach out to our home office at: 216-468-0050 to help address any outstanding concerns.


I have lived here before when I was younger, and I absolutely will be moving back here! The pools are great, and the apartments are really nice!


Was this helpful?
Thank you for the valued feedback - please feel free to reach out if there is anything we may do to help get you situated as you prepare to return. Thank you again!


office personnel rude and unhelpful


Was this helpful?


Lawrence Central High School

| 9–12

Belzer Middle School

| 6–8

Brook Park Elementary

| Pre-K–5

Cathedral High School

| 9–12
This information is provided directly by the property. Apartment Guide does not create, develop, contribute to, or endorse this content.

Helpful Information

Check Availability

(317) 456-0964
By submitting this form, you agree to RentPath's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.